Moderate riskFDA FoodClass II

Little Temptations Chocolatey Eyeballs recalled for undeclared milk

Little Temptations Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline) contain whey, a milk product, but were distributed in packaging that did not show milk on the label. The notice reports no injuries.

From the FDA notice · Read the official notice ↗

Update since first reported

  • Nov 3, 2026FDA classified this recall Class II

What to do

  1. Do not eat or give these candies to anyone with a milk allergy.
  2. Check the lot number on the bag, box, or jar against the lots listed in the notice: Card Header Bag 2022602, 2022604, 2022610, 2142611, 217610, 2172627; Acrylic Box and Eyeball Jar 1222626; Pouch Bag 2112618, 2172607, 2172633, 2172639, 2242601; Tag & Bell Bag 1222626.
  3. The notice doesn't say how to get a refund or replacement; contact Crystal Temptations or where you bought the product.

Is yours affected?

Compare your label or packaging with the recalled product.

Product
Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolatey Eyeballs ) Spooks and Spells, The product comes in the following sizes: Card Header Bag - 10 oz. Acrylic Box - 7 oz. Eyeball Jar - 10.5 oz. Pouch Bag 16 oz. Tag & Bell Bag 11 oz. . Packaged in the following container types: Bag, Box, Plastic Jar . 12 packages per case .
Sold in
AZ, TX, VA, GA, MA, NC, IN, NV, CA, NJ, CT, OH, WY
Made for
All ages

Details

Units affected
55, 048 pieces
Illnesses reported
None reported
Manufactured in
67 Porete Ave, North Arlington, New Jersey, United States
Classification
Class II
Recall number
H-0189-2027

In the FDA's words

Description
Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolatey Eyeballs ) Spooks and Spells, The product comes in the following sizes: Card Header Bag - 10 oz. Acrylic Box - 7 oz. Eyeball Jar - 10.5 oz. Pouch Bag 16 oz. Tag & Bell Bag 11 oz. . Packaged in the following container types: Bag, Box, Plastic Jar . 12 packages per case . Product packaging mix-up. Product containing whey (milk), were distributed in packaging that did not reveal the presence of milk. CARD HEADER BAG 2022602, 2022604, 2022610, 2142611, 217610, 2172627 ACRYLIC BOX 1222626 EYEBALL JAR 1222626 POUCH BAG 2112618, 2172607, 2172633, 2172639, 2242601 TAG & BELL BAG 1222626 Distribution: AZ, TX, VA, GA, MA, NC, IN, NV, CA, NJ, CT, OH, WY Affected quantity: 55, 048 pieces
Hazard
Product packaging mix-up. Product containing whey (milk), were distributed in packaging that did not reveal the presence of milk.

Also reported as

Related topics